The Vice President of the Superior Council of the Magistracy (CSM), Luís Azevedo Mendes, lamented that judges with media lawsuits are the target of disbelief actions, revealing that there are many anonymous complaints against these magistrates,
© iStock
15/11/2026
by
Lusa
O vice President of the Superior Council of the Magistracy (CSM), Luís Azevedo Mendes, today lamented that judges with media processes are the target of disbelief actions, revealing that there are many anonymous complaints against these magistrates, “in general” filed.
In May, Judge Judge Judge Ivo Rosa – author in 2021 of the instructive decision of the Operation Marquis process, which involves former Prime Minister José Socrates (2005-2011) – wrote to the President of the Republic, António José Seguro, and to the President of the Assembly of the Republic, José Pedro Aguiar-Branco, a letter in which he accuses the Public Ministry of persecuting him, defaming and trying to embarrass him by opening eight criminal investigations, all of which were filed.
Asked about the subject in an interview with Lusa about the 50th anniversary of the CSM, Luís Azevedo Mendes recalled that Ivo Rosa was not the only judge investigated by the Public Prosecutor.
“Just have an anonymous complaint with a minimum of consistency for there [crime investigation]. And obviously, the D.A. gives me all the information and there's plenty. In general, they're all filed, most of them judges don't even know. This was the case of Judge Ivo Rosa”, said the vice president of the management and discipline body of judges.
This, he added, is related to the fact that the magistrate had “the responsibility of an intensely mediatic process”, similar to others from the beginning of this century, such as the Casa Pia case, which apparently motivated “situations of judicialization of politics, which then, in response, led to the politicization of justice”, as if they were “all against each other, in great conspirative and manipulative maneuvers”.
“ I fully understand the discomfort of Judge Ivo Rosa in these circumstances, as I understand the discomfort of another judge who is in front of a process of this magnitude, with this level of exposure, and who is exposed to an action that can be decredibilizing ", stressed Luís Azevedo Mendes.
According to the vice president of the CSM, these decredibilizing actions aim to “interdependence and independent performance capacity in good condition”, similar to what happens in relation to other professions, such as journalism.
“This is what the Council is here for, to give confidence to the judges when needed,” he assured, saying, “only thanks to their preparation” and “their inner strength” is that these magistrates “can do better” their work.
The independence of the judges will be one of the topics under discussion at the XX Annual Meeting of the CSM, which will take place Thursday and Friday at the Pavilion of Portugal, in Lisbon, at the same time as the first Judiciary Tech Summit, with opening scheduled, in the same space, for Tuesday and for the dissemination of technologies to the area of Justice.

