An international study with Portuguese physicians reveals that Portugal may be underutilizing electroconvulsive therapy in the treatment of depression, schizophrenia and bipolar disease.
© Shutterstock
21/11/2026
by
Lusa
Um an international study with three portuguese physicians on the use of electroconvulsive therapy (ETC) in Europe revealed that Portugal may be underutilizing the use of this technique in the treatment of depression, schizophrenia or bipolar disease, among others.
A brief search on the ‘google’ allows us to reach images and synopsis of the film “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest” (“Flying over a nest of cuckoos”, in Portuguese), whose protagonist, played by Jack Nicholson, is subjected to electroshock treatments.
It is the electroconvulsive therapy, abbreviated TEE, which in the film appears applied without anesthesia, something that nowadays does not correspond to reality.
“ When we think of electroshocks we think of the most caricature part of the treatment and not the clinical part. Electroshocks are one of the safest and most effective interventions in psychiatry (...). They work in severe cases with intense symptoms such as suicidal ideation ", described to Lusa psychiatrist Manuel Gonçalves Pinho.
Professor and researcher at the Faculty of Medicine of the University of Porto (FMUP), Manuel Gonçalves Pinho is one of the Portuguese physicians who collaborated in an international study on the use of ETC, an analysis from which it was concluded that, in addition to the lack of access to treatment, one of the reasons for the underuse of electroshocks is the stigma and Portugal does not escape the rule.
“ We are not as badly positioned as Italy that, for cultural reasons related to the dictatorship period, sees electroshocks as punishment and not as treatment, but we are in the middle group, so down”, he said.
At the top of the most resorting countries are Norway, Denmark, Sweden, the United Kingdom and Germany. This first group follows that of Portugal and in the third are countries such as Italy, Austria or Slovenia. In Denmark, this treatment is used 20 times more than in Portugal.
In addition to Manuel Gonçalves Pinho, who works at ULS Tâmega and Sousa, Portuguese physicians Albino J. Oliveira-Maia, from the Champalimaud Foundation, and Pedro Frias, from the ULS of the Lower Alentejo/National School of Public Health participated in the study.
Coordinated by Richard Braithwaite (from Brighton and Sussex Medical School, United Kingdom) and George Kirov (from Cardiff University, United Kingdom), this research was published in June in the European Psychiatry scientific journal.
In Portugal, in 2024, 204 patients treated with ECT in public hospitals were registered, representing an estimated annual rate of 19.1 patients per million inhabitants.
In contrast, in the Nordic countries this rate exceeds 200 patients per million inhabitants. Denmark, for example, reached 383 patients per million inhabitants treated with ECT in 2024.
In the rest of the countries analyzed, the rates of use of this therapy vary from 31 to 87 per million annually.
Italy has a low rate of 2.7 per million.
In written information sent to Lusa, Albino J. Oliveira-Maia, who is also director of the Center for Digital Neurotherapeutics at the Champalimaud Foundation and professor of Psychiatry at the Universidade Nova de Lisboa, said that “although the optimal rate of use of this therapy is not known, the deviation between European countries suggests that patients are being deprived of vital medical care”, thus proving “need to ensure that this treatment, which saves lives, is offered to those who need it”.
The opinion is corroborated by Manuel Gonçalves Pinho, who also warns of other difficulties in the Portuguese context since the costs of the devices, the training of professionals, the absence of a national register to monitor the number of treatments and the need for coordination between psychiatrists and anesthesiologists.
“ Yeah, because CTS is only performed with anesthesia. The patient has no pain or consequence associated with the procedure in most cases, but this implies that the treatment is done in a hospital context with some supervision. An electrical stimulus is applied that causes a tonicoclonic seizure that is controlled and monitored by doctors and reverts after a few seconds. Most patients stay an hour, an hour and a half, in the hospital and then go to their lives without any consequence,” he described.
Still on the difficulty of access, the FMUP investigator revealed that the waiting list in Portugal is “great to make electroshocks in most hospitals because there is no response capacity, and naturally the most severe patients are selected”.
And Albino J. Oliveira-Maya is direct to the conclusion: “This is a treatment with decades of use and it is clear today that reduces mortality by suicide and other causes in people suffering from depression. It is very worrying that it is so little available”.
On the other hand, in order to participate in this study conducted in 15 countries, Portuguese physicians had to use a database of the Central Administration of the Health System (ACSS), so they safeguard that the Portuguese tax may, however, be defective, because it is restricted to patients hospitalized in public hospitals, excluding outpatient and private sector activities.
In Portugal there are currently 25 ECT centers, of which eight belong to the private sector.




