Nicotine pouches: Less harmful than cigarette or new form of addition?

Nicotine pouches: Less harmful than cigarette or new form of addition?

After government approval, nicotine bags continue to worry the scientific community. A pulmonologist tells us that the goal should focus on the release of “ nicotine dependence, rather than perpetuating it in a new form”.

© Shutterstock


16/06/2026
by

Inês Morais Monteiro

As nicotine pockets they represented, for a long time, a fertile ground for the development of health problems - there is so far a law that prohibited this consumption in Portugal.

 

Despite restrictions on minors, a month ago the Portuguese Government began to regulate the manufacture, marketing, labelling, advertising and supervision of these products. Remember here the approval of that law and the setting of maximum levels of the substance.

From then on, this advance in legislation has been seen as a setback by the health authorities.

To understand what this substance is about, which will become easier to access, we talked about Daniela Rodrigues, a pulmonologist from the Trofa Saúde Group.

The expert clarifies that nicotine bags are a “new product, with less than two decades of market use and growing popularity in several countries” and, therefore, the long-term effects also “are still insufficiently known”.

A discreet presentation, ed ease of use and availability of multiple flavors has contributed to their promotion as a innovative way to consume nicotine without using cigarettes.

However, according to the pulmonologist, the fact that they do not produce smoke “does not exempt these substances from health risks”.

“ It is a product with high addictive potential, not approved for smokinglessness ", adds.

Read the full interview below.

How are nicotine bags consumed?

Nicotine bags are placed between the gum and the upper lip, usually for 30 to 60 minutes. During this period, nicotine is released and absorbed through the oral mucosa, passing into the bloodstream.


© Shutterstock  

What is the difference between nicotine bags and conventional tobacco?

The main difference between these products and smoked tobacco is the absence of combustion and, as such, exposure to the thousands of toxic chemicals produced by this route.

However, that doesn't mean they're safe products. Nicotine is a highly additive substance responsible for maintaining dependence.

In addition, several studies have identified, in several scholarships, the presence of tobacco-specific nitrosamines, compounds classified as carcinogenic, although generally in much lower amounts than those found in cigarettes.

If the goal is to quit smoking, can this substance help?

The introduction of nicotine bags into the market was based on the theoretical assumption of the alternative to tobacco products. However, it is important to distinguish marketing from scientific evidence.

Currently, the safety and efficacy of nicotine bags as a strategy for quitting smoking are not established. The American Heart Association explicitly states that there is insufficient evidence for the use of these substances as a smoking cessation or risk reduction tool.

The Portuguese Society of Pulmonology has paid special attention to this issue, alerting to the risks of dependence on nicotine bags, especially in young people, at a time when advertising to them proliferates, including in major events, benefiting from a worrying legal void.

Who's been using the nicotine bags the most?

The nicotine bags are mainly used by smokers and ex-smokers, but have also been gaining popularity among young adults, including as an initial form of consumption.

What are the risks of the “modernized” form of consumption of this substance?

Nicotine is a highly additive and toxic substance for the adolescent's brain, which is still in development, particularly affecting regions of the brain that control attention, learning, humor and impulse control.

The acute effects of these substances are also highlighted, in particular: temporary increase in heart rate and blood pressure due to the stimulating effects of nicotine on the cardiovascular system, the risk is potentially higher in people with pre-existing heart disease.

How many bags of nicotine equal a cigarette?

There is no direct equivalence. One of the most worrying aspects identified in the studies is the enormous variability of nicotine content in the bags. Bags containing approximately 1.8 mg to 47.5 mg nicotine per unit are described.

One cigarette usually provides about 1 to 2 mg of nicotine effectively absorbed by the smoker. This means that some bags may provide quantities similar to those absorbed with a cigarette, while others may reach much higher exposures. In this line, some authors warn about the possibility of consumers underestimate the dose of nicotine they are receiving.

What do doctors want with all the alerts?

In general, the scientific community has stressed the importance of do not normalize one form of dependence based on comparison with another at higher risk. In view of the evidence currently available, the most prudent approach remains to prevent the start of consumption, promoting smoking cessation through proven methods and helping smokers to free themselves from nicotine dependence rather than perpetuate it in a new form.

logo_nacloset_285_285_4k_webp2
Privacy

This site uses cookies so that we can offer the best possible user experience. Cookies information is stored in your browser and perform functions such as recognizing it when you return to our website and helping our team understand which sections of the site you consider most interesting and useful.