Young man dies of cancer. Parents convicted of negligent homicide

Young man dies of cancer. Parents convicted of negligent homicide

An Italian couple was sentenced to two years in prison each for negligent murder after refusing conventional cancer treatments for their 14-year-old son, who died of an osteosarcoma. According to justice, parents opted for alternative therapies without clinical efficacy.

© Shutterstock


18/11/2026
by

News to Minutes

Othe parents of Francesco Gianello, a 14-year-old Italian boy who died in January 2024 due to an osteosarcoma in the femur, were sentenced to two years in prison each for negligent murder.

 

According to Corriere della Sera, parents – Martina Binotto and Luigi Gianello – were accused of not having submitted their child to appropriate treatments in Vicenza, Italy. 

Initially, the prosecutor had requested a 14-year sentence for each of them for voluntary murder, considering the parents responsible for the death of their child for refusing conventional cancer treatments.

However, during the closing allegations, the crime was changed to negligent homicide and the couple eventually managed to reduce one third of the sentence. 

During the trial, the prosecutor acknowledged that the main cause of death was the tumor, but stressed the criminal responsibility of the parents for continuing to resort to alternative treatments “in a careless and reckless way”, despite being aware of the dangers involved.

At the heart of the prosecution was the decision of the couple to interrupt, in March 2023, the diagnostic process at the Orthopedic Institute Rizzoli in Bologna.

Parents still gave their consent for a biopsy, but eventually they signed their son's hospital discharge to follow the advice of Matteo Penzo, a doctor linked to the old method of physician Geerd Hamer – who advocated that diseases, including cancer, are caused by emotional shocks and can be resolved without conventional medical treatments. 

The family also asked for the opinion of other doctors who supported the clinical course proposed by the specialized institute of Bologna. However, the parents eventually continued to follow Penzo’s recommendations.

Francesco was temporarily transferred to the Arcadinoi Wellness Center in Tuscany to be in contact with nature, but his health has worsened.

In April 2023, he was admitted to the hospital of Perugia and it was found that the tumor mass had increased from 125 to 220 millimeters and the pulmonary nodules had doubled.

Later, in September, he was transferred to a hospital in Vicenza to receive palliative care, and was discharged a few months later. However, a severe respiratory crisis, on January 4, 2024, forced him to re-hospitalize until his death on January 14. 

According to the charge, the delay in treatment after leaving the hospital in Bologna compromised the possibilities of relieving the adolescent's suffering and prolonging his life. Instead of conventional treatments, Francesco underwent Brufen-based therapy, clay and foot massages.

The defense attorneys, Lino and Jacopo Roetta, asked for the complete absolution of the parents, denying the existence of a causal relationship between their decisions and the death of their son.

They also asked the court to consider the “emotional tsunami” experienced by the couple in the face of the diagnosis and “desperate optimism dictated by love”, said Corriere della Sera. 

In addition, they argued that parents did not resort to “curandeiros” or “false gurus”, but to a doctor duly qualified to practice the profession, and that they were already fulfilling a kind of “natural perpetual prison” due to the death of their son.

logo_nacloset_285_285_4k_webp2
Privacy

This site uses cookies so that we can offer the best possible user experience. Cookies information is stored in your browser and perform functions such as recognizing it when you return to our website and helping our team understand which sections of the site you consider most interesting and useful.