The Constitutional Court rejected Daniel Adrião's new challenge and maintained his expulsion from the PS, considering that the sanction of the Socialist Jurisdiction Committee was not disproportionate.
© Blas Manuel / News To Minutes
18/11/2026
by
Lusa
O Constitutional Court (TC) rejected the new challenge posed by former PS militant Daniel Adrião and maintained his expulsion from the party for considering that the sanction of the socialist jurisdiction commission was not disproportionate.
The decision is contained in a judgment of the Ratton Palace, dated 10 November, on Daniel Adrião's request for a challenge against the decision of the National Jurisdiction Commission (CNJ) of the PS to expel him from the party for running in local elections on an independent list to a parish in Lisbon, against a socialist candidacy.
“ In the light of all the foregoing, the present challenge is dismissed, while the CNJ judgment that determined the expulsion of the Impugnant of the PS”, reads in the judgment.
Daniel Adrião argued that the sanction was disproportionate, asking that the circumstances in which he applied and his party career be evaluated, and claimed that he was denied defense guarantees, but the TC concludes that there was no “obvious disproportion that justifies the judicial censorship of the sanction”.
“CNJ was not limited to considering that the application was demonstrated and to extract the result of the expulsion, and gave a statement on the reasons put forward by Impugnant that the possible lack of political orientation or timely decision on the submission of a list of the PS did not legitimize the integration into a competing application”, TC considers.
The court also states, citing previous jurisprudence, that it is not for it to “find whether the penalties are appropriate to the seriousness of the infringements” and that, except in cases of manifest disproportionateness, it is up to the party’s bodies to assess the sanctions and the judges cannot replace this decision.
On April 25, Daniel Adrião told Lusa that the TC, in a judgment on a previous challenge request, had decided, “unambiguously”, to annul its expulsion from the PS, considering that this decision made it clear that the “expulsion was illegal and legally invalid”.
In that judgment, which gave reason to Adrião’s request for questioning, the judges of the Ratton Palace conclude that “the decision taken in the document notified to the challenger as a final decision determining his expulsion from the Party does not gather the elements necessary to qualify as ‘judgment’”.
In this new judgment, the TC refers to this decision, stressing that “it did not sit in a judgment of non-infringement or absence of disciplinary responsibility” of Daniel Adrião, but rather in the “inobservance of statutory and regulatory requirements of the decision-making act”.
“ Thus, there is no impossibility of further disciplinary action in relation to the conduct in question, nor the requirement to precede this action of a readmission deliberation, given that the replacement of the bond of affiliation constitutes, in the exposed terms, the effect of the annulment itself ", argue the judges, rejecting the argument that the PS could not again expel it without reintegrating it before.
In a note sent to Lusa, official source of the PS states that the decision “validates the disciplinary expulsion sanction applied by CNJ, recognizing the full legal, statutory and procedural compliance of the internal organs of the Socialist Party throughout the process”.




